Sachs - Symmetry In Electrodynamics.pdf
(
529 KB
)
Pobierz
SYMMETRY IN ELECTRODYNAMICS
SYMMETRY IN ELECTRODYNAMICS
From Special to General Relativity
Macro to Quantum Domains
Mendel Sachs
Department of Physics
State University of New York at Buffalo
This article is Chapter 11 in: Modern Nonlinear Optics, Part 1, Second Edition, Advances in Chemical Physics,
Volume 119. Editor: M. Evans. Series editors: I. Prigogine and S. A. Rice (ISBN 0-471-38736-3)
Copyright year: 2002. Copyright owner: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
This material is used by permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
This chapter is based on the part of my research program in general relativity on
electromagnetism. Most of it has been published, since the late 1950s, and is referred to in the
bibliography. The analysis of the theory of electromagnetism based on its underlying symmetry
in relativity theory is re-assembled here with added discussion
.
1. Introduction
An important lesson from Einstein’s theory of relativity is that the underlying
symmetry of any scientific theory reveals many far-reaching physical implications
that are not obvious at first glance. In regard to the subject of electrodynamics and
its unification with optics, the initially discovered relations in the 19
th
century,
between electrical charges and their motions and the resulting electric and magnetic
fields of force, led to a set of partial differential equations for the laws of
electrodynamics. The formalism was not completed until Maxwell saw the need,
based on
symmetry
, for an extra term in the equation that relates current density to a
resulting magnetic field. His addition of the extra term, called “displacement
current”, then yielded the full expression of “Maxwell’s equations”. The latter were
recognized as the laws of electrodynamics, which were then seen to incorporate the
laws of optics.
Indeed, it was Maxwell’s generalization of the laws of electrodynamics that
revealed that the radiation solutions of these equations, which would not have
appeared in the earlier version (without the displacement current term) predicted all
of the known optical phenomena. After Maxwell’s investigation of these optical
implications of electrodynamics, other portions of the spectrum of radiation
solutions were predicted and discovered empirically: radio waves, X-rays, infrared
radiation, gamma rays. Thus, it was Maxwell’s intuitive feeling for the need of
symmetry in his laws of electrodynamics that led to the full unification of
electrodynamics and optics in the expression of Maxwell’s equations.
James Clerk Maxwell died in 1879, the same year that Albert Einstein was born.
Sixteen years later Einstein recognized that Maxwell’s equations are
covariant
with
1
respect to the Lorentz transformations between relatively moving inertial frames of
reference i.e. reference frames that are in constant relative motion in a straight line.
That is to say, Einstein recognized in 1895 that the laws of electrodynamics,
expressed with Maxwell’s field equations, must be in one-to-one correspondence in
all possible inertial frames of reference,
from the view of any one of them
.
1
The set of transformations of the spacetime coordinates that project the laws of
electrodynamics from any observer’s reference frame to any other (continuously
connected) inertial frame such that the laws remain unchanged is the
symmetry group
of the theory of special relativity. It was discovered that this is the Poincare group.
2
Einstein then asserted, ten years later in 1905, that not only the laws of
electrodynamics and optics, but
all
of the laws of nature must be covariant under
the transformations of the symmetry group of relativity theory. This is the assertion
of “the theory of special relativity.” It is a statement of the objectivity of the laws of
nature regarding all possible inertial frames of reference.
3
In the next stage, Einstein generalized this symmetry rule to assert that all of the
laws of nature must remain objective (covariant) with respect to transformations
between frames of reference that are in arbitrary types of relative motion. This is
the “theory of general relativity”. As a first step, the theory of general relativity led
to a new explanation for the phenomenon of gravitation, agreeing with the
successful predictions of Newton’s theory of universal gravitation, but predicting
more effects not predicted by the classical theory. General Relativity thereby
superceded Newton’s law of universal gravitation.
4
A significant feature of general relativity is the role of geometry in the
mathematical representation of
all
of the laws of nature. For Einstein found that
the Euclidean (flat) spacetime was not an adequate logic to represent the laws of
interacting matter and radiation. Instead, he had to generalize to Riemannian
(curved) spacetime geometry. The implication was that all of the laws of nature,
including the laws of electrodynamics and optics, must be field laws that are
mapped in such a curved spacetime. Later on, in his quest for a unified field
theory, Einstein did insist that one should not only exploit the geometrical logic of
the spacetime language, but one should also exploit its algebra. Here he referred to
the underlying group of general relativity – which I have called “the Einstein
group”. In a 1945 article,
5
Einstein said: “Every attempt to establish a unified field
theory must start, in my opinion, from the group of transformations which is no
less general than that of the continuous transformations of the four coordinates”.
At the outset, then, it is important to recognize in our study of a generalization of
the laws of electrodynamics based on the full symmetry of relativity theory that its
covariance is in terms of a
continuous group
6
(whether we refer to special relativity or
to general relativity). Such a group does not admit the discrete reflections in space
or time. Further, because of the requirement of incorporating laws of conservation
of energy, momentum and angular momentum, in the flat spacetime limit of the
2
theory,
Noether’s theorem
prescribes that the transformations that define the
covariance in relativity theory must be analytic.
7
That is to say, the relativistically
covariant solutions of the laws of nature must be regular (i.e. nonsingular)
everywhere
.
8
Such groups of continuous, analytic transformations (the Poincare group
for special relativity
2
and the Einstein group for general relativity) are
Lie groups
.
9
They prescribe the algebraic logic of the theory of relativity.
In Section 2 there will be an outline of the generalization of the vector potential of
electromagnetic theory so as to include a gauge invariant
pseudovector
part. This is
allowed because of the lack of reflection symmetry in the relativity groups. In
Section 3 the full form of the equations of electrodynamics in terms of the
irreducible representations of the Lie groups of relativity theory will be shown. It is
a two-component spinor formalism that follows from a factorization of the
standard vector representation of the Maxwell formalism. In Section 4 the theory
will be extended to its full form in general relativity. It will be shown that the 16-
component quaternion metrical field equation emerges as a factorization of
Einstein’s (10-component) symmetric tensor field equations in general relativity,
once the reflection symmetry elements are removed from the underlying covariance
group. It is then demonstrated that these 16 independent field equations may be
re-written as a sum of 10 second -rank symmetric tensor equations, corresponding
exactly with the Einstein field equations, plus 6 second-rank antisymmteric tensor
equations. It is shown that the latter may be put into a form that corresponds
exactly with the formal structure of Maxwell’s equations. Thus, it is because of
removing the reflection symmetry elements from the underlying group of general
relativity, that one arrives at the factorized field equations that fully unify the
gravitational features of matter, in terms of Einstein’s field equations, with the
electromagnetic features of matter in terms of the Maxwell field equations. The
route
toward achieving a unified field theory from general relativity is then to follow
the rules of the underlying Lie group by removing the reflection symmetry
elements from the symmetry group of Einstein’s tensor field equations, thereby
yielding a natural structure of the formalism in terms of spinor and quaternion
variables. It will be seen in this analysis that, in accordance with a
generalized Mach
principle
,
10
the electromagnetic field of a charged body vanishes in a vacuum.
In Section 5 it will be shown that the quaternion structure of the fields that
correspond with the electromagnetic field tensor and its current density source,
implies a very important consequence for electromagnetism. It is that the local limit
of the time component of the 4-current density yields a
derived
normalization. The
latter is the condition that was
imposed
(originally by Max Born) to interpret
Quantum Mechanics as a probability calculus. Here, it is a derived result that is an
asymptotic feature (in the flat spacetime limit) of a field theory
that may not generally
be interpreted in terms of probabilities
. Thus, the derivation of the electromagnetic field
3
equations in general relativity reveals, as a bonus, a natural normalization condition
that is conventionally imposed in quantum mechanics.
2. A Generalization of the Electromagnetic Potential
After the momentous discovery by C.S. Wu and her collaborators in 1957 that the
weak interaction violates parity (spatial reflection),
11
I addressed the question on
whether there may be any empirical evidence for the violation of parity in the
electromagnetic interaction.
12
It was thought that only the weak
interaction violates space-reflection symmetry. But if, in the final analysis, there is a
unified field theory in which the weak and the electromagnetic forces, as well as all
of the other forces of nature, are manifestations of a single force field, then there is
an implication in the experimental result of Wu
et al
that the electromagnetic and
the nuclear forces also violate space-reflection symmetry, as well as time reversal
symmetry. Indeed, the
continuous group
that underlies relativity theory implies that
all
discrete symmetries must be excluded from the laws of nature.
At that time, in the 1950s, there was a problem whereby the calculations from
quantum electrodynamics for the Lamb shift, 2S
1/2
– 2P
1/2
in the states of
hydrogen, were not in exact agreement with the measurements. Thus it occurred to
me that a small violation of parity symmetry in the electromagnetic interaction
might be responsible for this discrepancy.
My investigation proceeded along the following line:
12
The conventional coupling
of an external electromagnetic potential field A
µ
to an electrical four-current density
of matter j
µ
is in terms of the
scalar
interaction Lagrangian,
L
int
(s)
= j
µ
A
µ
= e
ψ
(e)
+
γ
0
γ
µ
ψ
(e)
A
µ
(2.1)
ψ
(e)
is the (four-component) bispinor electron field that solves the Dirac
equation
4
[
γ
µ
(∂
µ
+ ieA
µ
) + m]
ψ
(e)
= 0 (2.2)
It is assumed here that the electromagnetic vector potential A
µ
is a (polar) four-
vector field. Thus the Lagrangian L
int
(s)
is a scalar function in space and time.
If parity should be violated, A
µ
may be generalized by adding an (axial)
pseudovector part, B
µ
to A
µ
. The Lagrangian then generalizes to a sum of a scalar
part and a pseudoscalar part, L
int
= L
int
(s)
+ L
int
(ps)
, where the latter part ,
e
ψ
+
γ
0
γ
µ
ψ
B
µ
, is clearly a pseudoscalar function.
Then what is the source of B
µ
in electromagnetic theory? Are there restrictions
on A
µ
that should also apply to B
µ
? The answer is yes – it is the restriction of gauge
invariance in order to yield a unique representation for the electric and magnetic
field variables. Additionally, gauge invariance is the necessary and sufficient
condition for the existence of conservation laws in the formalism – in this case the
requirement of the conservation of electrical charge.
13
The latter follows from the
continuity equation,
∂
µ
j
µ
= 0. (2.3)
The gauge covariance is in two parts: l) gauge invariance of the first kind, that is,
invariance of the formalism under the phase change
ψ
→
ψ
exp(i
η
), where, at this
stage,
η
(x) is an arbitrary scalar field, and 2) gauge invariance of the second kind -
applied to the vector potential, this is the change: A
µ
→
A
µ
+ ie
∂
µ
η
. The latter is
the addition of a four-gradient of the scalar field
η
to the original potential A
µ
.
Applying these two types of gauge transformations to the Dirac Equation (2.2)
then leaves it covariant, i.e. its form is left unchanged.
The Unique Form of B
µ
The form of the pseudovector potential B
µ
that is gauge invariant would be a field
that effectively interchanges the roles of the electric and magnetic field variables in
the interaction Hamiltonian that couples a charge q to external electric and
magnetic fields. For such a form leaves the electromagnetic interaction with
charged matter still dependent only on the electric and magnetic field variables,
directly.
The idea is the following: The electromagnetic field intensity solution of
Maxwell’s equations, expressed in terms of the four-dimensional curl of the vector
potential is:
F
µν
=
∂
µ
A
ν
-
∂
ν
A
µ
(2.4)
where the antisymmetric second-rank tensor F
µν
is the combination of the electric
and magnetic field variables,
E
and
H
, as follows: F
0k
= -F
k0
= E
k
, F
jk
= -F
kj
= H
n
and F
µµ
= 0., where j
≠
k
≠
n = 1, 2, 3 and the ‘0’ subscript is the time component.
F
µν
are the solutions of Maxwell’s equations:
∂
ν
F
µν
= 4
π
j
µ
,
∂
[ρ,
F
µν]
= 0 (2.5)
The ‘bracket’ in the second equation in (2.5) denotes a cyclic sum and we use units
(henceforth in this article) with c = 1. Combining the definition of F
µν
as the four-
dimensional curl of a four vector, as in eq. (2.4), Maxwell’s equations in terms of
the vector potential are:
5
A
µ
= 4
π
j
µ
(2.6)
where
is the D’Alembertian operator
∂
2
/
∂
t
2
-
∇
2
, and the vector potential is
subject to the
Lorentz gauge,
∂
µ
A
µ
= 0,
which in turn corresponds to selecting the phase
η
(x) to be a solution of the wave
equation,
η
= 0.
Since j
µ
is a four-vector field and
is a scalar operator, it follows that A
µ
is a
(polar)vector field. Let us now choose the (axial) pseudovector field B
µ
that
Plik z chomika:
andreas50_54
Inne pliki z tego folderu:
John Freeman - Suppressed & Incredible Inventions (1976).pdf
(8429 KB)
Aspden - ENERGY SCIENCE - AN INTRODUCTORY OVERVIEW (2004).pdf
(172 KB)
Aspden - ENERGY SCIENCE - A BRIEF REVIEW AND A CONCLUSION (2004).pdf
(111 KB)
Aspden - CYCLOTRON RESONANCE IN HUMAN BODY CELLS (1997).pdf
(220 KB)
Aspden - Conservative Hadron Interactions Exemplified by the Creation of the Kaon (1989).pdf
(655 KB)
Inne foldery tego chomika:
AUTO MAPA TomTOM NAJNOWSZA MAPA EUROPY GOTOWIEC NA KARTE
123 PIC Microcontroller Experiments for the Evil Genius
400,000 tys .Sterowników.PC+Laptop 2010.rok
ABBYY PDF Transformer 3. 0 Pro
ABBYY PDF Transformer.v3.0.100.216.PL Patch
Zgłoś jeśli
naruszono regulamin